November 8, 2026
The Tie that Binds
Ecclesiastes 4: 1-3, 7-12; Revelation 20-21
Rev. David Germer
Ecclesiastes 4:1-12
Again I saw all the oppressions that are practiced under the sun. Look, the tears of the oppressed—with no one to comfort them! On the side of their oppressors there was power—with no one to comfort them. And I commended the dead, who have already died, more than the living, who are still alive, but better than both is the one who has not yet been and has not seen the evil deeds that are done under the sun.
Then I saw that all toil and all skill in work come from one person’s envy of another. This also is vanity and a chasing after wind.
Fools fold their hands
and consume their own flesh.
Better is a handful with quiet
than two handfuls with toil
and a chasing after wind.
Again, I saw vanity under the sun: the case of solitary individuals, without sons or brothers; yet there is no end to all their toil, and their eyes are never satisfied with riches. “For whom am I toiling,” they ask, “and depriving myself of pleasure?” This also is vanity and an unhappy business.
Two are better than one because they have a good reward for their toil. For if they fall, one will lift up the other, but woe to one who is alone and falls and does not have another to help. Again, if two lie together, they keep warm, but how can one keep warm alone? And though one might prevail against another, two will withstand one. A threefold cord is not quickly broken.
That might be the second most known text in Ecclesiastes, because of its use in weddings. Our second reading is another text sometimes used in weddings. Neither of today’s passages are on the level of 1 Corinthians 13 or 1 John 4… but they do speak to the way that people are bound to one another. 2 are better than 1; a chord of 3 strands is not easily broken. And now hear these words, from Revelation 21:
Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth, for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away, and the sea was no more. And I saw the holy city, the new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared as a bride adorned for her husband. And I heard a loud voice from the throne saying, “See, the home of God is among mortals. He will dwell with them; they will be his peoples, and God himself will be with them and be their God; God will wipe every tear from their eyes. Death will be no more; mourning and crying and pain will be no more, for the first things have passed away.” And the one who was seated on the throne said, “See, I am making all things new.”
The word of the Lord. Thanks be to God.
Many of us heard a powerful message from Revelation 21 just two days ago, at the service witnessing to the resurrection of Jesus, in confident hope of the resurrection of Frank Dodson. Rev. Patti Kitchen told us that the word for new in that phrase – God making all things new – is not about chronological recency or about shininess but instead conveys new use – refurbishing and repurposing. It’s an appropriate and hopeful text for memorial services, and All Saints Day, and even for weddings. God does beautiful, new things, with what is, already. It’s also a great text to pair with Ecclesiastes 4.
Remember that Ecclesiastes has been primarily about the sometimes crushing inevitability of time marching on, and the seeming randomness or unfair chance of life, and the cold hard universal reality of pain and of death… But sometimes, the teacher offers a little hope. “Yes, life is confounding and can be miserable, so let’s acknowledge that, and recognize what is and is not in our control.” The teacher points, at times, to things that make life bearable.
I want to say up front: This is my last sermon here with you… and if I didn’t go just a little long today… wouldn’t you question everything you thought you knew about me?
You may not know this about me: I love a good ranked list, and I especially love to make a good ranked list. My 17 year old Josiah shares this trait with me. It’s not all movie lists… but it’s mostly movie lists. Best of the year, of the decade, of a director’s filmography. On family hikes that we’ve been taking since he was a toddler, Josiah and I used to rank our favorite Disney or Pixar or Star Wars movies. Just this past week, I got Naomi to rank her favorite candy, and I bet you could get Titus to give you his top five hiding spots for flashlight monster.
In today’s passage, the cynical teacher in Ecclesiastes, Qohelet, gives us a sort of ranked list – one that I think most of us would be surprised to find in Scripture. Did you catch this?
If we were to rank these conditions, these states of existence or being, from best to worst… how would you rank them?
– those who have died;
– those who are alive;
– those who have never been born.
For the teacher in Ecclesiastes, it’s this:
—#1 – Not yet been – Never born or conceived. Best case scenario. They are to be envied.
I actually studied and preached on this passage, in the summer of 2020… when, you know, everything from 2020 was happening, and we really didn’t need Qohelet’s reminders of how awful the world could be… and on top of that, Tracy was about 4 months pregnant with Naomi. A super encouraging passage, if you are about to bring a child into the world. Better not to be born at all, Qohelet says.
—Second best, #2: those who lived but whose suffering is over – the dead.
—And: Worst of all of, coming in dead last: those who are alive. Pity the living, the teacher in Ecclesiastes says.
Is the teacher right? Don’t rush to answer that. We’re conditioned to immediately dismiss that, as unfaithful… so maybe let’s ask this question, instead: Does the teacher at least have a point?
There is a so much suffering, and evil, and oppression in the world, and the news makes sure we know this. There’s a lot of pain, and brokenness, and injustice in our community, right now.
Those of us sitting in this room: major operations, unexpected doctor visits and diagnoses, grief over the loss of friends and family members, deep pain over fractured relationships.
I need to be honest and say that this sermon would have had a little different resonance and bent, had the midterm elections gone differently. Some of us might be inclined, particularly this week, to say: “Things actually could be a whole lot worse. Do we even need Ecclesiastes anymore? Things are looking up. We might be headed in the right direction!” Some of you let me know this week you feel better about me heading to Texas, now, than you did last week. And I get it, and to be clear: I share some of those feelings. But I would push back a little, on any narrative that reaches into the realm of placing cosmic significance on this week’s election results.
If we think that this week wiped out corruption, or even that we are now one step closer to the kingdom of God on earth as it is in heaven… I want to caution us. I don’t mean to suggest that the election results don’t matter or don’t have massive implications, at time even life-and-death, for many made in the image of God. They do. But we aren’t going to vote ourselves into the kingdom of God. We aren’t going to elect our way out of what the teacher in Ecclesiastes is saying about the reality of the world: time marches on, life is often random and unfair, and death is coming. And that’s no less relevant today, than it was last Sunday and Monday.
We still need the wisdom of Ecclesiastes.
It’s part of a thematic trilogy in Scripture – along with Proverbs and Job, making up the wisdom literature. You may be familiar with a framework that Walter Breuggemann and other scholars used for understanding the vast array of outlooks and emotions and prayers captured in another book in the Hebrew Scriptures, the Psalms.
This is an oversimplification, but I think a helpful one: There are psalms of orientation, telling us that there is a sensible and somewhat predictable and reliable order to the way the world works: trust and obey God and do good, and things go well. There are psalms of disorientation, saying, well… except when they don’t. Sometimes the unjust and unrighteous come out on top, and things aren’t the way they should be, and it’s terrible, and makes me want to lash out at God or other people. There are psalms giving full expression to that.
And then there are Psalms of reorientation, that say, in effect: but God… but God is still good, and is still God, and has a way of working good out of the bad, creating and finding beauty out of brokenness.
The wisdom literature works similarly. Proverbs, by and large: orientation. These little succinct and often pithy or beautiful or surprising phrases that are so helpful, and truly wise. Proverbs is orienting – it takes us by the hand and points the way forward, saying, you want the good life? Follow me.
But then Qohelet in Ecclesiastes comes along to disorient us – the teacher grabs us not by the hand but by the shoulders, and says: the good life is smoke, vapor, vanity – hevel. Qohelet uses the word 38 times in 11 chapters, and it doesn’t mean that life is meaningless, as it’s sometimes translated… it just means it’s an enigma, ungraspable, absurd, a mystery.
Then Job steps up to say, yes indeed, in fact it may be even worse than Ecclesiastes lets on… “but God” nevertheless is with us, and is faithful, and beyond our understanding, and does not leave us alone.
The book of Revelation, like Psalms, gives us all three.
And this can be confusing for those who like to talk about “the biblical worldview” or “biblical perspective,” as if there is only one. It’s almost as though the Bible is trolling itself, by including these wisdom books, as a set. I read someone say that the Bible’s arguments with itself would get it kicked out of an online chatroom for deliberate emotional provocation; rage-baiting, some might say.
But we need this kind of nuance and perspective and wrestling with the full spectrum of the complexity of life, which Qohelet rightly calls hevel – enigmatic, mysterious. We need to be prepared for the fact that no matter how you feel this week about the future of our country, sin and brokenness are just as real today as they were on Monday, and we are just as deeply in need of a savior… and it’s not Roy Cooper or Jamie Ager or Kim Roney or even James Talarico.
I’ve been thinking a lot this week, and really the past month, about my need for a savior. It’s been an emotionally hard month. Some of you were here in this very room, almost five years ago, when Shannon and I were installed – a moment and service that in a way, is a little like a wedding – and my brother Kevin provided the charge for me. He’s a pastor, and so he used his time and his words well, and was pretty eloquent and stirring… but he basically said: remember that you don’t need FPCA. He said that it might be tempting to connect how the church and the ministries that I’m involved in are doing, to how I’m doing, to find in it, and in them, my meaning and identity. And he said something that I’ve tried to remember, and sometimes done a better job at remembering and believing than other times: Your deepest need (my deepest need), is to know and trust and live on the basis of God’s unswerving love for me in Jesus. What I most need is the deep, relentless love of the triune God, and I have that.
He also said: (and he was talking to me… but I think he knew others were listening) “remember that FPCA doesn’t need you.” He said some very kind things about my gifts, and expressed confidence in my calling, but said that ultimately, the person FPCA most needs is not you, but Jesus. He said that they need to know his endless love for them. That you need to know the goodness and grace of life under his lordship. You need to see and experience him as an all-sufficient savior.
And that is such a comfort to me, and maybe a needed reminder, for some of us, in this time of transition. I will be gone soon. Shannon will leave a week later, for sabbatical. At some point, Patrick and Caitlin won’t be here. And it’s true about each one of us: you don’t need us… but you do need Jesus, just as we do.
Kevin ended by saying: because of those two things – you don’t need them, and they don’t need you – you are free. Free to serve and love with joy and gratitude, without fear, and to be loved with joy and gratitude. And that’s what I think we’ve done a lot of, together.
It’s a strange, at times absurd, ungraspable, enigmatic thing, that we pastors are called to do: come get to know and love a congregation, bond with them, connect your life to theirs, in profound ways… and be ready to leave, and live by and boundaries that can seem, in a way, to undo those very chords you’ve been weaving together for years.
In that sense, ministry itself is often hevel… As it must be, because so is life, and what is ministry, if not trying to live fully alive to God, and to help others do the same.
I want to tell you a story of one of my favorite ungraspable, hevel moments in ministry.
At the Montreat Youth Conference that our senior high youth participate in every summer, we have a tradition at the end of the week. We’ve spent the week worshipping together, listening to and learning from sermons and keynotes, wrestling with the parts that are challenging, staying up late playing games… and on Friday night, after the closing worship and sending liturgy, with hundreds of youth and gathered around Lake Susan, singing together by candlelight, our group returns to Sally Campbell to write affirmations to one another. This is a tradition that I believe Michael Poulos started decades ago, and it is so beautiful, because the youth pour their hearts out to each other, naming what they see in and love about each other, encouraging one another, and, often, crying their way through the process. This goes so long (in the best way), that we’ve found we actually need to split it up – to take a break. A couple years we tried to go get food, but learned that no restaurants in Black Mountain or even Swannanoa are still open at 1:00 am, so instead, we started turning this needed break into an opportunity for some play, and adventure.
One year we played Capture the Flag in a field… but in complete silence, so that we wouldn’t disturb anyone at that hour. One year we parked our bus near the Montreat speed-check signs that flash your vehicle speed, to confirm that indeed it would also clock foot speed. You wouldn’t believe the amount of fun mileage we got out of silent foot-races.
This year, I wanted to do something different, so I scoped out the entire town, and discovered a new field, with what I was sure was a brilliant idea: middle of the night kick-ball. By the time we got to the field, it was clear that this was not such a great idea: the youth (and other adult leader) were, I’m pretty sure, a little annoyed, because we had to hike up what amounted to several flights of stairs just to get there, and once we did, we could hold our hands out in front of us and not see them… which was going to make kickball a challenge.
After some failed attempts, a few youth quickly gave up and laid down on the grass, and soon, the entire group had joined them, because we discovered that while we couldn’t see a few feet in front of us… above us was a canopy of shining stars. We’d spent the week reflecting on the life of faithful following of Jesus as a life of wondering and wandering… and here we all were, suddenly, capping this incredible week, with a completely unspoken, unplanned group silent reflection… that lasted roughly 10 minutes. Do you know how hard it is for a group of a dozen youth to hold 10 minutes of silence? They did this, with zero planning or prompting from me or anyone else. Nobody had to be shushed. Everyone intuitively knew.
I could not have orchestrated that moment… and even by talking about it, I’ve risked softening its power by imposing my meaning onto it; it may have meant something completely different to each one of us, under the stars that night. Ecclesiastes says that’s ok. Don’t try to define or cling to or grasp exactly what it was that gave life such meaning in that moment; hold onto it all with an open hand, and choose, simply, to enjoy it.
“Yes,” the teacher says, “there are things outside of our control; life sometimes does not feel fair; time marches on and ultimately we are pretty insignificant; we are all going to die…” Yes. Oppression and tears abound – now, as always… But we don’t labor or live alone.
And so what God has been comforting me with, this week, is this: The bonds of ministry aren’t undone, if it was true ministry… because true ministry is about connecting people with each other, and with the One who we most deeply need. God calls us to be fully alive as we live with Jesus, in community, because a cord weaved by God through the love, support, and care of communities like this one; the tie that binds us – Jesus himself – does not fray or loosen or snap when met with challenge or change or death or departure. Jesus can take those realities, and add more strands, more beloved children of God. Jesus catches them up and says, you belong here, too; you have purpose and meaning here, also; you will make us stronger, and more beautiful.
Jesus is making all things new – here in this place. And, if you’ll let him: in you. What new thing, in this season, might Jesus be calling you into, or calling forth in you? We’ll take a minute or two of silence to reflect and pray. And I’d invite you to share what you hear, or what you’re wondering about, with a friend or family member or even a pastor. Blest be those ties that bind. Blest be the tie we share, in Jesus, our Savior, our deepest need. Let’s pray: God, what are you calling me into? What are you calling forth, in me?